This listing is for a PICK-UP ONLY pre-order Eggnog Ice Cream Pie!
A holiday favorite that is new this year, our eggnog ice cream pie features a graham crust with caramel swirled in the bottom. Then it is topped with homemade eggnog ice cream. We finish off the top with whip and winter spices-- this pie is unique enough to compliment the other desserts at your holiday gathering, and if it's as freezing cold as a midwest Christmas can be, you can store it outside on the porch until it's ready to eat!
Pies will be available for pick-up beginning Thursday, Dec 18, 2025 at 10 AM through Tuesday 12/23/24 at 9 PM. Limited pies will be available, so please pre-order!
Choose Local Pick-up at checkout- we do not ship ice cream!
Also note that it takes over 24 hours to make an ice cream pie. Last chance to pre-order a pie is Tuesday 12/16/25! Limited pies will be available in-store without pre-order, but they will go fast! Pre-order to ensure you get your pie in time for the holidays! :)
